While not necessarily crashing, Supergirl’s season finale certainly didn’t stick the landing either. On that front, it stayed in line with the inconsistent tone of the season.
That cool showdown between a Myriad influenced Alex and Supergirl seemed poised to be the season’s ultimate high stakes family fight. Instead, Alex tossed Kara around in her robo-suit before J’onn arrived with Eliza Danvers to snap her daughter out of this previously indefensible mind control device.
And just how did J’onn escape from Indigo, know Alex was gunning for Supergirl, travel back to get Eliza and bring her back in time before Alex killed Supergirl? Sure seems like an invisible assist to knock Alex out would have been far more effective.
For all the buildup right down to Superman’s Kryptonian robots being afraid to even utter the word, Myriad sure was a letdown. Supergirl’s broadcast message of hope, love and cat videos was enough to snap Myriad’s control. That was pretty weak given the circumstances.
And given that Indigo showed full control over the Internet and presumably all airwaves, not to mention Non’s complete control over people to simply turn off the TV, phones or tablets, it was a real stretch they would allow Kara’s message to get out in the first place. I still want to know what Non had the Catco employees working on in the office.
Myriad wasn’t a complete loss though as Superman was inexplicably still under its control despite literally everyone else in National City being fine and back to normal. I get Superman hasn’t been cast, but it’s so much easier explaining his absence as being in outer space or dealing with a threat with the Justice League than coming up with these nonsensical methods to keep him on the bench.
Non and Indigo had one last play – cranking up Myriad to overload and eventually For the next 20 minutes, Supergirl – the earlier beacon of hope and optimism – now confronts the problem with a sense of helplessness. Apparently her Hope Tank was on empty.
Despite a rash of logistical and After rallying the citizens of National City with a message of hope, Kara spends most of the season finale all but admitting defeat and saying farewell to all her pals awaiting their deaths.
Gen. Lane arrives to throw shade on J’onn while Max tracks Non’s base to the one place you’d think the DEO would’ve checked already – Fort Rozz. Well, in fairness, no one at the alien task force organization knew the location of the prison containing all these prisoners. I see why Lois doesn’t trust you General.
Just when it seemed the Non/Indigo clash with Supergirl and Martian Manhunter would make up for the lackluster Myriad deal, Supergirl and Manhunter get pretty decisive wins. Earlier in the season, Non seemed pretty capable of beating Supergirl, but this time he simply resorts to spewing out heat vision and hoping for the best?
With Myriad still counting down to Earth’s eradication, Supergirl flies it out to orbit. For the sake of some drama, Supergirl apparently is unable to fly into space. While the ahem space-breathing MARTIAN is apparently fine watching this play out, Alex won’t let her sister sacrifice herself and takes Kara’s pod into space to rescue her. Since when did Alex learn Kryptonian let alone get a pilot’s license or determine if she’d be safe in the pod? Sigh.
Despite these numerous complaints, Melissa Benoist continues to carry this show through its roughest patches. Supergirl’s plea to Alex to have a normal life was a strong scene as was Cat giving Kara her own office and the sweet moment where she actually pronounces her name correctly. It seemed way out of character for Cat to give Kara carte blanche in deciding her future at Catco, but it was a well-earned moment in an episode short of them.
Team Supergirl celebrates at Alex and Kara’s. Eliza, now clued in that Jeremiah isn’t dead, insists on a plate setting for him while James seizes the moment to kiss Kara. And still not interested in this romantic pairing.
Before they finish busting out the bubbly, a Kryptonian pod crash lands in the distance. If it’s anything but Krypto in that Krypton pod I’m going to be very disappointed.
Rating: 6.5 out of 10
For Benoist’s sake, I’m counting on a second season one where the writers come up with better plots and storylines. A lot of the shakier ideas this season got overlooked due to the novelty of a female superhero show, but for those expecting more out of the genre, season 2 needs to step it up.